Monomoy rewards a specific interest more than a general one. The calendar matters more than the weather.
April and May. Terns return and set up. Horseshoe crabs spawn on the flats, and the shorebirds that time their migration to that spawn arrive to feed. Piping plovers begin nesting on open sand, which is when beach closures start going up.
June to early August. The tern colony is at full volume, and it is a genuinely loud, dense thing. Chicks on the ground mean the tightest closures of the year. This is also when seal numbers on the bars are easiest to see from a boat.
Late August into October. Southbound shorebird migration, and the best and least crowded birding of the year here. Red knots, sanderlings, plovers and godwits work the flats.
November to March. Wintering sea ducks, eiders and loons offshore. Grey seal pupping in the region. Very few people, weather that decides whether any boat leaves at all, and a Morris Island trail that is bleak in the best sense.
Whatever the month, take the closure signs literally. A nesting plover will not move, and a footprint in the wrong place is the difference between a chick and no chick.